Summary:
Matt George and Mark Zockoll test how a Christian school should handle admissions. Matt argues for applying policy consistently. Mark argues for leaving room for the administrator’s judgment. They work through four tough scenarios and ask whether you could defend your admissions policy “as though you were a lawyer in court.” The topic matters for schools weighing the federal tax credit scholarship and facility expansion.
In This Episode:
-
The format: Matt takes the “consistent policy” side and Mark takes the “administrator’s wisdom” side, a format they say they may try again.
-
The struggling student: A fifth grader is well below grade level, but the parents share the school’s mission and will pay for tutoring. Matt says the answer depends on the school’s mission and what its policy says. Mark asks whether teachers who are already stretched have room for the student.
-
The challenging parents: A student has excellent grades, but the parents say they expect the administration to fix any disagreement with a teacher. Matt asks why a family would enroll if it already expects problems. Mark says the answer might depend on the teacher, and that he sometimes accepts families for the child’s sake.
-
The pastor’s son: A supportive local pastor’s child has been suspended elsewhere for disrespect and defiance, not fighting. Matt suggests a probationary period with clear expectations. Mark says he’d want to know what happened and when, and that safety isn’t up for negotiation.
-
The donor question: Can a donor influence an admissions decision? Matt says a donor should never change your policy or mission. Mark has seen it happen. The hosts discuss “no respecter of persons” and the difference between making room and skipping the line.
-
Policy vs. judgment: If standards can’t change, what are you paying an administrator for? They agree the question is whether you trust the person or committee applying the policy.
Follow Us:
YouTube: Christian Principals Podcast
Instagram: @cprincipalspod
Email: info@christianprincipalspodcast.com
Website: http://www.christianprincipalspodcast.com
X: @CPrincipalsPod
LinkedIn: Christian Principals Podcast
Explore the Herzog Foundation’s offerings for Christian schools at http://www.herzogfoundation.com. Book us for your next event to bring engaging and practical conversations to your community! And be sure to level up your school experience with our partner, Gradelink Student Information Systems, at cpp.gradelink.com today!
Thank you for listening and for leading with integrity in your school!